Timberframe vs ICF

Timberframe vs ICF

This post touches on one of the choices you encounter when researching self-builds, the build methods themselves. There are two main branches, traditional brick/masonry vs quicker ICF and then timberframe vs SIP. Basically concrete vs timber. We're not using fibre glass or exploring straw bale, mud or other methods here.

So if you've attended any of the shows you'll already have seen samples of Timberframe and ICF. I've been thinking about the merits of each but come to the conclusion, as have others, that the method doesn't really matter as much as the construction company themselves. It's akin to buying cattle, don't check the cattle, check the seller!

So, the most important thing is to get a feel for the company themselves, how long have they been around, have you read about them in online forums and was the feedback positive? As you'll be paying a deposit, it might be worth getting a credit check done, especially if there is a dip in the market as some are on shakier financial footing and won't tell you.

I've approached MBC Timberframe myself and liked what they have to say and what's been said about them online. So for that reason I'll be lining them up on my shortlist. I'm also not as drawn to 22 meters squared of concrete as I am to Scandinavian Timber & Warmcell insulation from a carbon footprint point of view. The thought of living in a timber house appeals to me more even though from the outside after building, it's not going to be possible to tell the difference. There are fire safety concerns but using the right materials and mitigating solutions such as watermist suppression systems can be designed in.

So, I'm not going to 'diss either method as both are good and provide a solid home. Do a bit of research and see if you can visit a home they built and ask about any issues encountered, and more importantly, how they went about fixing those issues. That's the nugget that can swing me, problems will occur but will a company roll up their sleeves and put it right straight away or not?

Whatever method you end up with I hope it's a smooth build and you're happy with the end product after 1, 2 or 5+ years afterwards. There should be no creaks or cracks if the work is solid or any dampness intruding into your dream home after it's complete. You may have to hang kitchen units and your 60 inch TV a slightly different way but as long as that's it and it performs well, who cares?!